BILL HURLEY LURES- A CAPE COD CLASSIC

A Cape Cod classic built for perfectly replicating what stripers love to eat most.

When it comes to Northeast striped bass fishing—especially around Cape Cod—few niche lures have developed the cult following of Bill Hurley lures. These aren’t mass-produced, flashy tackle shop gimmicks. Instead, they’re purpose-built, fish-catching tools designed around one thing: perfectly imitating sand eels and american eels, two of the most important forage species for stripers along the Cape Cod coast.

Background & Design Philosophy

Bill Hurley began making lures back in the 1980s after struggling to find anything that truly matched sand eel profiles during trips to the Cape.  His solution was simple but effective—create a slender, soft-plastic bait that looks, moves, and even smells like the real thing.

That philosophy still defines his lineup today.

The flagship models—like the Cape Cod Sand Eel and the well-known “Striper Magnet”—feature:

• Long, thin “mouse-tail” profiles

• Large, prominent eyes (a known striper trigger)

• Soft plastic bodies infused with sand eel oil scent

• Pre-rigged jig heads with top quality hooks

• 
  

Performance

When They Excel

Bill Hurley lures are at their absolute best when bass are keyed in on sand eels—a common scenario throughout the Northeast all throughout the fishing season.

• Highly effective during spring and fall runs

• Deadly in clear water with pressured fish

• Ideal for finicky stripers refusing larger or louder lures

In fact, many Goose Hummock customers regularly include Hurley sand eels among their go-to soft plastics.

Effectiveness

One of the biggest strengths of Bill Hurley lures is their ability to produce when nothing else will. Anglers have reported getting hits immediately after switching to them during tough bites.

Why?

• Ultra-realistic profile matches natural forage almost perfectly

• Scent infusion adds an extra trigger when fish are hesitant

• Subtle action works well on slow retrieves or light jigging

This makes them a true “confidence bait” when the bite gets picky.

Build Quality & Components

• Strong, dependable hooks (often paired with quality jig heads)

• Durable enough for multiple fish—but still a soft plastic

• Available in multiple weights (¾ oz, 1 oz, 2 oz, etc.) for varying conditions

That said, like most soft plastics, they will get torn up—especially by bluefish.

Pros

Pros

• Extremely realistic sand eel imitation

• Scent-enhanced for added effectiveness

• Proven striper catcher in tough conditions

• Excellent casting distance due to slim profile

• Simple to fish (great for beginners and experts alike)

Best Situations to Use Them

• Sand eel presence

• Back bays, rips, and surf zones

• Cold water or pressured fisheries

• When stripers are ignoring larger plugs

Bill Hurley lures are not hype—they’re specialized tools that excel in a very specific but common scenario: matching sand eels during striper season.

They may not replace your entire plug bag, but when the bite gets tough, they can absolutely save a trip. In many cases, they’re the difference between getting skunked and putting fish on the sand.

If you fish the Cape or anywhere sand eels are present, they’re a must-have in your lineup.

SHOP BILL HURLEY