Fall Trout Fishing on Cape Cod

When most anglers on Cape Cod start shifting their focus to stripers, albies, and bluefish in the fall, a quieter, equally rewarding fishery opens up in the region’s ponds: trout. Thanks to well-managed stocking programs and the cooling temperatures, autumn is one of the best times of year to target trout on the Cape.

Why Fall Is Prime Time

Trout thrive in cooler water, and as summer heat fades, Cape Cod’s kettle ponds settle into perfect conditions for them. The crisp mornings and shortened days bring water temperatures into the 50s and 60s—ideal for rainbow, brook, and brown trout to feed aggressively. Unlike in spring, when trout are freshly stocked and scattered, fall trout are often larger, hungrier, and more active.

Adding to the excitement, the Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife conducts a second stocking each fall, releasing thousands of rainbow and brown trout across Cape Cod’s freshwater ponds. These fish mix with the holdovers from spring and can provide fast action well into November.

Where to Go

Cape Cod is blessed with dozens of deep, clean kettle ponds carved by glaciers, and many of them are stocked with trout. Some of the most popular and productive fall trout ponds include:

• Cliff Pond (Brewster) – Known for its depth and clear water, it holds trout year-round and fishes especially well in fall.

• Sheep Pond (Brewster) – A perennial favorite, with good shore access and excellent chances for larger browns.

• Flax Pond (Nickerson State Park) – Easily accessible and often heavily stocked, making it a great choice for consistent action.

• Peters Pond (Sandwich) – One of the Cape’s larger ponds, productive for both stocked trout and holdovers.

Almost every town on Cape Cod has at least one pond that receives trout, so anglers don’t need to travel far to find good fishing.

Tactics and Gear

Fall trout can be caught using a variety of methods:

• Bait Fishing: PowerBait, live shiners, and nightcrawlers are reliable choices, especially when fished under a slip bobber or on the bottom.

• Spinning Tackle: Small spoons (like Kastmasters), inline spinners (Mepps, Rooster Tails), and jerkbaits are deadly on actively feeding trout.

• Fly Fishing: Cooler water and active fish make for excellent fly fishing opportunities. Woolly Buggers, streamers, and small nymphs often produce, with early mornings and overcast days being prime times.

Light spinning or fly tackle is ideal, as trout are often line-shy in Cape Cod’s clear kettle ponds.

The Experience

Fall trout fishing on Cape Cod isn’t just about the catching—it’s about the setting. The kettle ponds are surrounded by brilliant foliage, the summer crowds are gone, and the water is often still and quiet. For anglers looking for a more relaxed pace after the chaos of the saltwater season, a day casting for trout in a glassy pond is hard to beat.

Whether you’re chasing rainbows fresh from the fall stocking truck or hunting for holdover browns that have grown fat over the summer, Cape Cod’s ponds offer some of the best trout fishing in Massachusetts during autumn. As the saltwater bite winds down, don’t overlook the chance to spend a crisp fall day on the pond with light tackle and trout on the line.

Shop Goose Trout Gear